The Pepperwood Bay witches continue their search for Ms. Fiddleneck's missing magical teapot. Ms. Fiddleneck's magical teapot is still missing, and the Pepperwood Bay witches are hard at work trying to find out what happened. But very quickly during their next investigation, they realize that something seems off, and the sisters are then thrown into chaos that threatens to uproot their sunny island lives. Can they put everything right again, even if they disagree on how it's done?